Skip to content

Supplier Evaluation Matrix Builder

Rate each supplier on quality, on-time delivery, cost and service with weights that match your priorities. Totals and ranks are calculated; download the scorecard for the supplier review.

Supplier scorecard

Packaging suppliers — Q3 2026

CriterionWeight (%)Smurfit WestRockMondiDS SmithLocal Box Co
Quality (PPM defects)304543
On-time delivery255434
Cost competitiveness203345
Responsiveness104345
Sustainability104542
Innovation53432
Weighted total400410370370
Rank#2#1#3#3

5 = ≥ 98% on time / < 50 PPM · 1 = < 85% on time / > 1,000 PPM.

About the Supplier Evaluation Matrix Builder

It opens on the Supplier scorecard example: quarterly scorecard for four packaging suppliers with percentage weights. Pick a Matrix switches to 3 more templates: Vendor selection matrix (three logistics providers scored before awarding a two-year contract); Supplier segmentation (Kraljic) (purchase categories placed by profit impact and supply risk to set a strategy for each); Supplier performance review (kPIs against targets for each supplier, with status and the agreed action).

Weights and scores are the only inputs. The weighted totals, the rank of each option and the winner are worked out for you, and the Excel download keeps them as live formulas, so the matrix still adds up after someone changes a score. When it is ready, download an editable PowerPoint slide built from native tables and shapes, an Excel workbook with drop-downs, colors and formulas, a PNG image or a CSV file. It is free, with no sign-up, and nothing you type is stored.

4 Supplier Evaluation Matrix templates

Every template opens filled in. Pick the closest one, then change anything.

How to use the Supplier Evaluation Matrix Builder

  1. 1

    Pick a matrix

    Click Pick a Matrix. This page has 4 ready-made templates, such as Supplier scorecard and Vendor selection matrix. Each opens filled in — pick the closest one.

  2. 2

    Edit the matrix

    Type the weight of each criterion and a score for each option. The weighted totals, the rank and the best option update as you type.

  3. 3

    Add rows, columns or items

    + Add adds a row, column, criterion, item or risk. Rename the matrix in the title box; Undo (Ctrl+Z) reverses any change.

  4. 4

    Download

    Download lists every format: a PDF (landscape, one page), an editable PowerPoint slide with native tables and shapes, Excel with drop-downs, colors and formulas, a PNG image, CSV, and a project file to open again later.

Key terms

Supplier scorecard
A regular report that scores a supplier on agreed KPIs such as quality, delivery and cost.
PPM
Parts per million — defective parts for every million delivered.
OTIF
On time in full: the share of orders delivered on the agreed date and in the right quantity.
Kraljic matrix
A 2×2 that sorts purchases by profit impact and supply risk into strategic, leverage, bottleneck and non-critical.
Vendor selection
Choosing a new supplier by scoring bids against weighted criteria.

Questions

What is a supplier evaluation matrix?

A table that rates suppliers on weighted criteria such as quality, delivery, cost and service, so you can compare them and decide who to keep, develop or replace.

What should a supplier scorecard include?

Usually quality (defects or returns), on-time delivery, cost against target, responsiveness and sometimes sustainability, each with a weight, a target and the actual result.

What is supplier segmentation?

Grouping suppliers by how much they affect profit and how risky the supply is — the Kraljic matrix — so strategic suppliers get partnerships and non-critical ones get simple, low-cost buying.

Is there a free vendor scorecard template in Excel?

Yes. Build the scorecard here and download Excel with the weights and scores kept editable.

Can I download the supplier evaluation matrix as PowerPoint or Excel?

Yes. The PowerPoint download is an editable slide built from native tables and shapes, and the Excel workbook keeps drop-downs, colors and formulas. PNG and CSV are there too. It is free, with no sign-up.

Goes well with this — from our other free tools

Example content is illustrative and exists so each page opens with a finished matrix. Replace it with yours before sharing.